Reader Profiles, rochester

Reader Profile – Larry Marx


Larry Marx is CEO of The Children’s Agenda, a Rochester-based organization advocating for policy change and evidence-based solutions for the health, education, and success of children. Larry has been an organizer and leader of political campaigns and social change organizations for the past 30 years, working in more than one hundred issue and election campaigns in Illinois, Wisconsin, Minnesota and New York. Larry co-chaired the board of the national Partnership for America’s Children for three years, a network of 56 state and local children’s advocacy organizations in 44 states. He is an appointee to the Governor’s Early Childhood Advisory Council and the New York State Child Care Availability Task Force, and serves on the Executive Committee of ROC the Future and the Steering Committee of the Rochester-Monroe Anti-Poverty Initiative. Larry received the awards named after the founders of Action for a Better Community and the Rochester chapter of the National Council for Jewish Women in 2016. He is married to Deb Rosen and has two college-age daughters, Natalie and Naomi. They make their home in the Neighborhood of the Arts in Rochester.

What character or author would be the librarian in your personal literary paradise? 

It would have to be Tintin, the intrepid reporter from the Hergé series of what we now call graphic novels.  The literary paradise he would bring me would be based on truth-telling, unfaltering moral purpose, travels to faraway lands, known and unknown, and breathtaking adventures with thrilling escapes.  Plus, there would be lifelong friendships along the way with Chang, Captain Haddock, and my ever-faithful dog Snowy.

How do you treat the books you read? Do you make notes in them? Dog-ear the pages? Keep every page (and the spine!) pristine? 

If they’re nonfiction, then quite likely I’ll write marginalia. It used to be a point of pride to mark those books up, kind of like an animal scent-marking its turf – Larry was here!  I think of it as places , connections and thoughts I might want to return to, especially for work.  But fiction, good fiction, is indelible in itself, so I like to leave those books untouched and immaculate. 

Do you ever judge a book by its cover? What attracts you to a cover? 

Wow, definitely.  If I don’t know the author, then an intriguing title is my first and foremost point of attraction, followed by cool cover art.

What was the first book you read by yourself as a child? 

Truly can’t remember.  I’m old.

Is there a book you’ve read that you wish you didn’t? 

I majored in political science and philosophy, and several Germans – especially Heidegger’s Being and Time – plunged me into both quandaries and depression.  Also Stephen King’s It.  I was so profoundly angry and disgusted at the turn the book takes at the end, I almost threw it away. It completely ruined for me what had been a great read over a long time.

What is the funniest book you ever read? 

Jim Harrison had a series of novellas about a character named Brown Dog, an indigenous man from Michigan’s Upper Peninsula .  His bawdy antics are wonderfully LOL and enlivening.

Have you ever decided NOT to do something based on what you read in a book? 

Yes, continue reading philosophy.

What book marks a major milestone in your life? 

A glorious summer when I lived in D.C. and read War and Peace. I bought a used hardback, 50th anniversary translation, that included a bookmark/booklet comprised of maps, character lists, and timelines that I referred to constantly.  I was fully immersed for the summer summer in a deep, moving experience.  And I think of Alice Walker’s The Color Purple, Salman Rushdie’s Midnight’s Children, Wendy Mogel’s The Blessings of a Skinned Knee. . . The chapters of my life are definitely book-marked.

Do you have a favorite picture book? What and why? 

In addition to everything Tintin, there’s a gorgeous graphic novel called Habibi, by Craig Thompson, which we read in my book club.  The images are Islamic-influenced, exquisite black-and-white pen lines swirling on the page – a real feast for the eye.

What was the last book you read that challenged your world view? 

I read Peter Singer’s Animal Liberation as a 19-year-old and became close to being a lifelong vegetarian ever since.  White Fragility – mirrors are hard on the eye (of the beholder). More recently, Ruth Ozecki’s The Book of Emptiness and Form and Grace Cho’s Tastes Like War both changed my understanding of the “madness” of people who hear voices. The Book of Emptiness and Form also has beautiful scenes of a library as a place of sanctuary, belonging and sanity, where books whisper rather than shout.

Have you ever read a book by your favorite author that you did not enjoy? 

Yes, I devoured Jim Harrison’s works for many years.  The language in his poetry and his nonfiction writing about food and wine stayed fresh, but the themes and language of his late novels got repetitively stale, unfortunately.

Is there an author or a book that you think is highly overrated? Why? 

Sorry, Henry James is booooring.

What book would you recommend to heal a broken heart? 

Pretty much anything ever written by the magnificent Louise Erdrich: Love Medicine, LaRose. . .  I cannot read her without getting choked up, my heart cracking open, like Leonard Cohen’s “Ring the Bells:”

Ring the bells that still can ring,
Forget your perfect offering
There is a crack, a crack in everything
That’s how the light gets in

Is there a book you’re embarrassed to have read? What and why? 

No longer being a teenager, I shall pass on this question.

What is a favorite quote from a book? 

Is this cheating? Richard Wagamese, an Ojibwe author and journalist, had this to say on a wall I spotted in July at Toronto’s Art Gallery of Ontario:

“All that we are is story.  From the moment we are born to the time we continue on our spirit journey, we are involved in the creation of the story of our time here. It is what we arrive with.  It is all we leave behind. We are not the things we accumulate. We are not the things we deem important.  We are story. All of us. What comes to matter then is the creation of the best possible story we can while we’re here: you, me, us, together. When we can do that and we take the time to share those stories with each other, we get bigger inside, we see each other, we recognize our kinship – we change the world, one story at a time.”

If you had a Narnia closet, what literary world would it lead to and what’s the first thing you would do there? 

Probably David Mitchell’s The Thousand Autumns of Jacob de Zoet.  And I would immediately scream, run and hide for my life from the evil lurking there.

You’re on a dating app and all your matches are literary characters. Who do you select? 

Can I please date authors?  Padma Lakshmi, Louise Erdrich, Jesmyn Ward, Elena Ferrante (blind date), Patti Smith, Debbie Harry, Nora Ephron, Jennifer Egan. . .

Where do you get your book recommendations? 

I like to follow certain authors, so once I find a book I really like, I’ll start running after them until I either catch up or I’m out of breath.  I’m part of a book club, too, and those become my reading priorities.  And then I also like the New York Times book review, and whatever flotsam gets kicked up to my phone by the various algorithms tracking my every online move.

If you enjoyed this Reader Profile and are interested in doing one yourself, please contact me at patricia.uttaro (at) libraryweb.org.

Reader Profiles

Reader Profile – Maren Kyle


Maren is an outreach librarian in Rochester, NY who still takes Levar Burton’s word for it, even though you don’t have to. Apart from her first love, books, Maren also enjoys trivia, board games, and walks in the woods with her family.

What are you reading right now? 

Lightfall, which is a middle grade fantasy graphic novel series, Samantha Irby’s latest book of essays, Quietly Hostile, and I’m finally getting round to reading Middlemarch by George Eliot! These days I always have a few books going at once.

The desert island question – What 5 books would you have to have with you if you were stranded on a desert island and why? 

I don’t know if this is a cheat, but first of all: a really big poetry anthology– Norton or FSG. Then, I’d go for a couple of tomes that I’ve always wanted to read but have never managed to make the time for: Don Quixote and Moby Dick. Finally, the old familiar favorites, Grimm’s Fairy Tales and Parable of the Sower by Octavia Butler.

Who is your go-to author when someone asks you for a recommendation? 

I guess I don’t have a go-to. I believe in a book for every reader and a reader for every book, so I rarely make recommendations without knowing something first about the person’s preferences. If I was really pressed to recommend something I’ve enjoyed, I suppose I would say Justin Cronin is an author I love that I think has a wide appeal.

Describe your favorite place to read.  

Lounge chair in the backyard with my dog in the grass next to me and my kids playing outside…down the block at the neighbor’s house!

Book or movie? Is there a movie that you think was better than the book? 

I would say that the book is usually better because they are such vastly different mediums and it takes incredible nuance to transfer a great book into a great movie.  But even when it is done very well (Lord of the Rings or Shawshank Redemption come to mind), I usually still prefer the book because I am a book person!

Share a favorite quote from a book you’ve read. Why is it meaningful to you?  

Well, I think it’s in Dirk Gently’s Holisitic Detective Agency that Douglas Adams wrote “Let us think the unthinkable, let us do the undoable, let us prepare to grapple with the ineffable itself, and see if we may not eff it after all.” I often get bogged down by the can’ts and the shouldn’ts, and that quote reminds me to forget about all of that and just go for it. Plus, it makes me laugh.

Is there a book you feel is highly overrated? 

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. Sure, there are a couple of interesting twists and turns, but besides that most of the book is dry descriptions of this guy eating sandwiches, reviewing his notes, and going for walks.

Are there any books that marked milestones in your life? 

Maybe not a specific book, but I think of my late teens (end of high school…starting college) as my “Kerouac years.”

Are you a “finisher” or do stop reading a book if you’re not connecting with it? 

You know, I used to finish a book no matter what but there’s just too many other books that I want to read to waste my time on something that I’m not getting anything out of.

Do you have a favorite book that you received as a gift? 

When my first child was born, we were given many books, including a complete collection of the Frog and Toad stories by Arnold Lobel. I suppose technically the gift wasn’t given to me, but believe me I definitely received it.  Now I frequently give the same book as a gift to new parents and their babies.

Do you judge a book by its cover?  

I try not to dismiss a book because of its ugly cover, but a couple of my favorite books I never would have read if I hadn’t said “Hey, what’s that? It looks cool!”

What was your favorite book when you were a child? 

The Ramona books by Beverly Cleary, especially Ramona the Pest. I’ve never encountered a literary character that I relate to more.

What book made you laugh out loud? What book made you cry? 

I cry every time I read the end of Turtles All the Way Down by John Green, which is not the John Green book everybody expects you to cry over, and yet…

If you are interested in doing a Reader Profile, please reach out to me at patricia.uttaro (a) libraryweb.org.

Reader Profiles, Women

Reader Profile – Grace Engelbrecht


Grace Engelbrecht is a public librarian whose home library as a child was the Gates Public Library. Outside of reading, Grace plays co-ed softball, enjoys movies, trivia and board games, and values relaxing days with her husband and son. She loves a good snack, especially popcorn on nights in at home or out at the movies. Grace hopes to finish writing her romance novel someday. Until then…

How do you treat the books you read? Do you make notes in them? Dog-ear the pages? Keep every page (and the spine!) pristine?

I treat my books well; no dog-earring for me! Recently for the first time, I highlighted and annotated a fiction book, which felt wrong and unusual, but I think when I want to peruse through it later, I’ll have notes of what stood out to me. 

Do you ever judge a book by its cover? What attracts you to a cover?  

Absolutely! I think it’s hard not to. I love covers that are colorful or cutesy or things with bold text. I don’t tend to gravitate towards darker covers.

Where do you get your book recommendations?

I am part of the ‘Bookstagram’ community, bookish posters on Instagram and that’s a lot of fun. I see a lot of great books that I’m interested in, and people are so great about sharing indie recommendations that maybe I wouldn’t have come across otherwise.

What is something you dislike in a book?

I would say the most annoying would be lack of quotation marks on dialogue. In college, we were assigned The Waves by Virginia Woolf, which is a stream of consciousness novel, so the lack of quotation marks makes sense, however the stream would jump from character to character without any text change and I just couldn’t get through it. 

What is the funniest book you ever read?  

When I was a teenager, I read a British series called The Confessions of Georgia Nicolson by Louise Rennison. She was a highschooler with many mishaps and embarrassing moments and I remember laughing and snorting out loud when I was reading during homeroom or lunch. I’m not sure if the humor would hold up now, but I really enjoyed those at the time. 

You’re on a dating app and all your matches are literary characters. Who do you select?  

The ‘classic’ choice would probably be Mr. Darcy from Pride & Prejudice. Most recently, I enjoyed Daniel Grant from Part of Your World by Abby Jimenez and Leon from The Flatshare by Beth O’Leary.  I love a supportive and sweet book boyfriend.

What book marks a major milestone in your life?  

The Doll People by Ann M. Martin and Laura Godwin is very special to me. It was really the first time I remember reading a chapter book by myself, while being so engrossed in a magical and adventurous story. I read that book five or six times. 

Do you have a favorite picture book? What and why?  

My favorite picture book as a child was Roxaboxen by Alice McLerran, illustrated by Barbara Cooney. It was read to me in school, then I asked for a copy at home. It captures childhood imagination and nostalgia so beautifully. Now, reading to my son, one of my favorites is You Are My I Love You by Maryann K. Cusimano, illustrated by Satome Ichikawa. It’s a poignant rhyming story of a parent and child’s relationship: “I am your water wings; you are my deep. I am your open arms; you are my running leap” is one example of the couplets in that book.

Is there an author or a book that you think is highly overrated? Why?  

I think the ‘it’ contemporary author right now is Colleen Hoover. I have listened to two of her books and liked them. However, the obsession going on right now, I don’t quite understand. There are many contemporary romances that are just as well-written, if not more so. I don’t think Hoover is the superstar of romance above all others. She is good, but I wasn’t blown away. 

What book would you recommend to heal a broken heart?  

This is a tough one. There is some heartbreak in The Reading List by Sara Nisha Adams, but the story is hopeful and uplifting. It’s insightfulness into human connection was striking.

What is a favorite quote from a book?

My favorite book is Me Before You by Jojo Moyes, so if I were to pick something from that, it would be from Will’s letter: “Live boldy…Push yourself. Don’t settle…Just live well. Just live.” I think given the story, Louisa really needed those words and she was inspired by them. To me, it’s a gentle reminder to make special the ordinary, dive into experiences when I can, and breath into the rest.

Reader Profiles

Reader Profile – Timothy Ryan


Timothy M. Ryan, MLS, MSJ: Timothy has been the Director of the East Rochester Public Library since 2020. Prior to ER, he worked at the Seymour Library in Brockport, and the Lincoln and Sully branches of the Rochester Public Library. He is a recipient of the American Library Association’s 2017 I Love My Librarian award. Timothy grew up in Brockport, but currently resides in Greece with his wife Ty, sons Preston, Hayden, and Lawson, step-daughter Ellie, and step-son Romeo.

What character or author would be the librarian in your personal literary paradise?

Dennis Williams. Author of Tree People & Parker’s Problem

What was the first book you read by yourself as a child?

The Twits by Roald Dahl – It may not actually be the first book I read by myself, but it’s the first that I can remember. I must have read it over and over at least 10 times in 2nd grade.

Is there a book you’ve read that you wish you didn’t?

Just about every book the school system ever assigned me to read, but The Indian in the Cupboard and The Scarlet Letter are two that I wish I could have the time back from reading.

What book marks a major milestone in your life?

God, Art, and Other Random Thoughts by Timothy Ryan because it was the first book I had ever published. (Available for purchase on Amazon or to borrow in the MCLS catalog at https://libraryweb.org).

Do you have a favorite picture book? What and why?

Sylvester and the Magic Pebble – This is my favorite picture book because it’s the first book that I can remember being read aloud to me as a child by both my mother & father. It’s also the first book that evoked an emotional response from me that I still can remember to this day.

What was the last book you read that challenged your world view?

Capital in the Twenty-First Century by Thomas Piketty

Is there an author or a book that you think is highly overrated? Why?

Anything by James Patterson……. predictable.

What is a favorite quote from a book?

“We are but shadows and dust (Pulvis et umbra sumus)” – (Horace, The Odes)

If you had a Narnia closet, what literary world would it lead to and what’s the first thing you would do there?

Middle Earth……smoke a pipe with Gandalf.

You’re on a dating app and all your matches are literacy characters. Who do you select?

Saeko Busujima – High School of the Dead

Reader Profiles

Reader Profile – Jennifer Byrnes


Jennifer is the Head of the Business Insight Center at the Central Library of Rochester & Monroe County (NY). An avid reader since leaving the womb, she grew up going to the Paddy Hill Public Library in Greece NY every other day. She strongly believes you are never too old to read Pigeon books.

What are you reading right now? 

Bastard Out of Carolina by Dorothy Allison. It’s my book club pick for this month.

The desert island question – What 5 books would you have to have with you if you were stranded on a desert island and why?

Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass – And What Alice Found There by Lewis Carroll. They have so many layers you could read them a hundred times and always notice something new.

Man’s Search for Meaning by Victor Frankl. If someone can find meaning while living in a concentration camp, then I can survive a desert island.

The Three Pillars of Zen by Roshi Phillip Kapleau. I may as well reach enlightenment if I have nothing to do.

The Poetry of Edward Lear. To remind me to be on the lookout for a sieve. They went to sea in a sieve they did, in a sieve they went to sea…

Who is your go-to author when someone asks you for a recommendation?

I love Anchee Min.

What book do you wish you’d never read? 

Mein Kampf by Adolf Hitler.

Has any book defined your life, as in you would be a different person if you hadn’t read it?

Everyday Zen by Charlotte Joko Beck. Everyday, and everything, is practice.

Describe your favorite place to read.

On my deck in the summertime.

Book or movie? Is there a movie that you think was better than the book?

Never!

Share a favorite quote from a book you’ve read. Why is it meaningful to you?

“We’re all mad here. I’m mad. You’re mad.” – The Cheshire Cat. Don’t take yourself too seriously.

What book challenged you the most when you read it?

The Sound and the Fury by William Faulkner. I knew if I just stuck with it, that it would eventually make sense, and it did!

Is there a book you feel is highly overrated?

Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace. One should be able to get their point across in less than 1,000 pages.

Are there any books that marked milestones in your life? 

Are You There God, It’s Me, Margaret? by Judy Blume. I read it on a weekly basis from the ages of 7 to 9

Are you a “finisher” or do stop reading a book if you’re not connecting with it?

I’m a tried a true quitter. Which is why my book club hates me.

Why do you read?

It’s one of the most effective ways to get out of your own head.

Who would you choose to narrate your favorite book?

Someone British. They make everything sound better.

Where do you get your reading recommendations?

Friends, New York Times and Wall Street Journal.

Do you have a favorite book that you received as a gift?

More Annotated Alice (an annotated edition of Alice in Wonderland/Through the Looking Glass) from my grandmother Sophie.

Do you judge a book by it’s cover?

I try not to, but, I’m human.

What was your favorite book when you were a child?

I loved to steal my mother’s Danielle Steele books.

What book made you laugh out loud? What book made you cry?

I cry if I read Goodnight Moon; it reminds me of curling up with my daughter when she was little.  Are You There Vodka, It’s Me Chelsea by Chelsea Handler. A rollicking good time.

If you are interested in doing a Reader Profile here, email me at puttaro (at) libraryweb.org.

Reader Profiles

Reader Profile – Claire Talbot


Claire Talbot is a librarian at the Greece Public Library and oversees Adult and Teen programming. She organizes “Greece Reads” – an annual book and author visit, Glimpses of Greece photography contest, and hosts the library podcast “Book Break.” She leads two adult book discussion groups: “As the Page Turns” group and a historical fiction group on Facebook. Claire also purchases the bulk of the adult non-fiction collection for the library, and especially loves cookbooks. When Claire is not reading, she loves photographing birds, watching British mystery shows, and visiting her three children.

What character or author would be the librarian in your personal literary paradise?

I am a big Ann Patchett fan! I admire her writing, but also appreciate that she is a bookstore owner – Parnassus Books in Nashville TN. Parnassus does an Instagram video each Tuesday called “The Lowdown Diaries” which I watch faithfully.

How do you treat the books you read? Do you make notes in them? Dog-ear the pages? Keep every page (and the spine!) pristine?

I treat my books nicely and try to keep the cover and pages intact. I buy many books, and donate a lot of books. Some I raffle off in my book club. I would love to make a Christmas tree made of books – maybe 2023 will be the year I accomplish this!

Do you ever judge a book by its cover? What attracts you to a cover?

Oh yes! I have heard the siren song of a gorgeous cover! I am drawn to richly illustrated covers. Some of my Book of the Month Club choices are Peach Blossom Spring, River Sing Me Home, Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow and Spells for Forgetting. I choose them by reading the synopsis, but I have to say a pretty cover turns my head and grabs my attention!

What was the first book you read by yourself as a child?

I was lucky – my mother was a teacher and started me reading early. One of her gifts to me was The Cat in the Hat Beginner Book Dictionary – it was illustrated by P. D. Eastman – I loved his illustrations, and his books Go Do Go and Sam and the Firefly were two of my favorites that I read frequently as a child.

Is there a book you have read that you wish you did not?

Being an avid reader, I have finished quite a few that I thought “Wow – I wish I could get that time back!.” One I can remember is The Mermaid Chair by Sue Monk Kidd. I also was not a fan of the Twilight series, but I felt compelled to read them since I was a teen librarian at that time.

What is the funniest book you have ever read?

Believe it or not, I would laugh aloud at many of the stories featured in All Creatures Great and Small the veterinarian series by James Herriot. I read the entire series and just loved those books. Heads up: there are some tear jerkers in those books, too!

Do you have a favorite picture book? What and why?

I loved the Edith and Mr. Bear books. They are sometimes called The Lonely Doll series and were written by photographer Dale Wright. I still love reading picture books and loved the story of the owl in the Christmas tree at Rockefeller Center. One of the funniest picture books I read was How are you Peeling: Foods with Moods by Saxton Freymann that features photographs of vegetables that are so expressive!

What was the last book you read that challenged your world view?

Babel by R. F. Kuang – although I did not “love” this book it did make me really think about colonization and the power of language. I also read Lightning Strike by Willaim Kent Kruger for one of my book clubs and it really made me think about how we as a country have treated Native Americans, and the position in which we place children of mixed race.

Have you ever read a book by your favorite author that you did not enjoy?

Yes, I really love Pat Conroy but did not enjoy South of Broad. I also love Ann Patchett but did not love State of Wonder.

What is a favorite quote from a book?

I do love quotes, and when I read I keep a notebook close by that I can record passages of the book that touch me. It is difficult for me to name a “favorite” but I can share some that I have recorded recently. From the poem A Summer Day by Mary Oliver: “Tell me, what is it you plan to do with your one wild and precious life.” I also was struck by passage in Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin where Bong Cha (Sam’s grandmother) said, “There are no ghosts, but up here (gestures to head) it’s a haunted house.”

Where do you get your book recommendations?

I read library journals, Book Page, belong to Book of the Month Club, get recommendations from friends, and I listen to podcasts. Although I have a huge “To Be Read” pile I am always looking for new suggestions and I am easily distracted by new releases! Some of the podcasts I listen to are The Currently Reading Podcast, Literally Reading, and Book Talk, ETC. I also follow the Bibliolifestyle on Instagram – she creates beautiful reading guides each season which include book recommendations by genre, and fun things like cocktail recipes. I also am an avid “Goodreads” user and love their lists! 

Reader Profiles

Reader Profile – Adrienne Pettinelli


Adrienne Pettinelli is the Director of the Henrietta Public Library in Rochester NY and author of Helping Homeschoolers in the Library (2008, ALA Editions). She’s served on several book award committees, including the 2015 Caldecott Selection Committee, and she’s a reviewer specializing in picture books and beginning readers for Horn Book Magazine. She teaches for the University of Wisconsin-Madison and the University of Tennessee at Knoxville. When she’s not reading, Adrienne is trying to squeeze every bit of fun and happiness as she can out of her life with her husband, family, friends, three cats, and sweet little puppy named Bob.  

Is there an author or a book that you think is highly overrated? Why?  

Yes, oh my gosh, Lolita by Vladimir Nabokov. Nabokov knows how to write a sentence, and I think he captures the self-delusion of an active pedophile, but also this book mostly has the place in the canon* it does because of the large number of people who fetishize it and have a little too much in common with Humbert Humbert, which is gross. I think people can read the book and get an angle on an ugly aspect humanity, sure (and no doubt it’s effective, because I read it 25 years ago and am still irritated about it), but also, as a woman who was once a young girl fending off people like Humbert—a common experience—I have a hard time understanding why this perspective is held up so highly when so many other excellent books are considered niche reading. I’m thinking of a book like Passing by Nella Larsen, which is finally finding its more correct place in the canon, being largely ignored for many years while college students were being forced to read Lolita instead. There are examples of powerful writing that examine more worthwhile subjects, is my point. The NYT recently ran this great interview with Walter Mosley, and the way he talks about Philip Roth is kind of how I feel about Lolita (as well as most of Roth’s work, aside from “The Conversion of the Jews,” which is brilliant). 

As a coda, here’s the one people will fight me on—I couldn’t even get past like chapter five in Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn. When you Google the title, one of the suggested alternate searches is, “What is the point of Gone Girl?” Google is wrong a lot, but in this case, I concede the floor to Google. 

*I don’t believe in the whole concept of the canon, btw, but that’s a whole other subject, and also I can’t deny that the canon exists even though I don’t love it.  

Is there a book you’ve read that you wish you didn’t?  

The Song of Ice and Fire series by George R.R. Martin. It’s like I started and then got in too deep to quit, even though I am clearly never going to get some of those images out of my head, and my belief is that Martin isn’t even going to finish the dang series. Now I’m just here having invested in these giant, violent, misogynistic tomes, and I can’t even see how the stories end.  

Do not talk to me about the TV show. 

What was the first book you read by yourself as a child?  

It must have been Swimmy by Leo Lionni or Our Animal Friends at Maple Hill Farm by the Provensens, which are books I read until they fell to pieces and deeply shaped my perspective on life.  

Do you have a favorite picture book? What and why?  

You’re talking to a picture book expert here, so the answer is way too many to list. Today, though, I’ll pick Nana in the City by Lauren Castillo, which is a perfect, beautiful, life-affirming book, and I have a piece of art from it tattooed on my leg. When you love a book enough to put a piece of it on yourself permanently, I suppose that’s a solid candidate for favorite.   

What book would you recommend to heal a broken heart?  

Lean into your broken heart with some teen fiction. I myself love a teen romance when I’m feeling defeated. Nick and Norah’s Infinite Playlist by Rachel Cohn and David Levithan has it all—heartbreak, drama, humor, new love, music.  

What is a favorite quote from a book?  

From A River Runs Through It by Norman Maclean:  

“My father was very sure about certain matters pertaining to the universe. To him all good things—trout as well as eternal salvation—come by grace and grace comes by art and art does not come easy.”  

I first read this when I was nineteen, and I’ve returned to it and this book again and again in the thirty years since. It’s as close as I can get to a personal life philosophy.  

How do you treat the books you read? Do you make notes in them? Dog-ear the pages? Keep every page (and the spine!) pristine?  

I believe the only worth a book can have is in being read, so I’m not precious about how I handle books. I read a lot of library books, and I’m careful with those. I also buy books that I only intend to read once or twice and then pass on, and I’m careful with those, too. Books in my personal collection are written on, they’re dog-eared, they have broken spines. I find reading so enjoyable, but also I consider myself a student of both literature and life, and I read primarily to learn and, I hope, grow and maybe even become a slightly better human. All my books are workbooks.  

Where do you get your book recommendations?  

I get a lot of great book recommendations from friends and colleagues—I know many readers! I also learn about a lot of books from listening to the All the Books podcast from Book Riot (highly recommended for anyone looking to diversify their reading), and I get a lot from reading Horn Book Magazine (which I also write for).  

What is the funniest book you ever read?  

How am I supposed to pick? I love funny books, and I read and reread so many of them! People don’t think of The Odyssey by Homer as hilarious, but oh my gosh, that story’s nuts. Always makes me laugh. An offbeat favorite is Three Men in a Boat (To Say Nothing of the Dog) by Jerome K. Jerome, a 19th Century slightly-fictionalized account of a trio of ill-prepared men taking a boat trip on the Thames. And then after you’ve read that, you simply must read To Say Nothing of the Dog, Connie Willis’s raucous time-travel novel that riffs on Three Men in a Boat. Almost everything by Connie Willis is funny. Cold Comfort Farm by Stella Gibbons is another book that reliably makes me laugh out loud. If you want to laugh, I also recommend books by Jenny Lawson, Phoebe Robinson, Sarah Vowell, David Sedaris, Allie Brosh, and Mindy Kaling. I haven’t even gotten into children’s and teen books and authors. I could write a book about funny books.  

Do you ever judge a book by its cover? What attracts you to a cover?  

Yes, totally. I always think I’m going to like books with black covers and books with bright pink covers. I like a bold image—more graphic than not, but also I’ll respond to any cover that is striking in some way. I don’t enjoy reading rebound library books that have those plain cloth covers; I feel the lack of cover art as a loss. I’m someone who will happily engage in a lengthy argument about which cover art is best for favorite books and authors, and I get angry when excellent books are given unattractive or misleading covers. I can’t conceive not having strong feelings about these things, honestly.  

If you had a Narnia closet, what literary world would it lead to and what’s the first thing you would do there?  

I am a reader of sci-fi and fantasy, and I often hear people say things like, “I wish I could visit Narnia” or “I wish I could visit Hogwarts,” but way too many bad things happen in those places. I do not want to go to any of them. That counts double for any time in the past, when women were subjugated and no one had refrigeration or washing machines or antibiotics. No, thank you.  

You know what I would like to do, though? I’d like to go sit in the kitchen with Golly and have cake and milk. I’d like to follow Harriet around all day, in fact, but instead of writing in my notebook, I’d just copy everything she ate, because everything she ate sounds delicious. So I guess that’s where my Narnia closet would go. Either that or I’d like to go to one of Julia Child’s kitchens, although perhaps not on one of the days when she dropped the chicken on the floor.  

What was the last book you read that challenged your world view?  

I feel like I read a lot of books that nudge my world view, but challenge is a big thing. I’d say Riot Baby by Tochi Onyebuchi is the last book that profoundly changed my understanding of some things. It’s this tiny little novella that has the impact of a supernova.  

Thank you, Adrienne, for this insightful profile! If you are interested in doing a Reader Profile, please contact me at patricia.uttaro (a) gmail.com.

Reader Profiles

Reader Profile – Beth Larter


Beth Larter in front of the Arnett Branch of the Rochester Public Library. Photo by Quajay Donnell.

Beth Larter is a public elementary school librarian who has been a loyal library visitor since well before she learned how to read. She is passionate about education and the Rochester community. Her favorite activities outside of school include taking pictures on her film camera, rock climbing, and spending time with her family.

What character or author would be the librarian in your personal literary paradise?

I would want a library that had been created by the author Amy Krouse Rosenthal, who was one of the funniest and most insightful authors I have read and also had an incredible gift for seeing and developing the best parts of the people who knew her. I think she would develop a really wonderful and fun collection.

As a school librarian, do you have books that you recommend again and again to kids?

Every kid is so different, so the books I recommend are also really different. But one book I recommend a lot to my students who like graphic novels is the book New Kid by Jerry Craft. I also like to recommend one of my personal favorites from when I was younger, Ella Enchanted, by Gail Carson Levine.

Do you ever judge a book by its cover? What attracts you to a cover?

I absolutely judge a book by its cover– if the cover is a really good one. I am extremely impressed by the cover design artists who can capture the mood and themes of a book. It’s really the mood that the cover communicates that attracts me to a book.

What is the funniest book you ever read?

I think the Squirrel Girl comics by Ryan North were some of the funniest books I’ve ever read. The characters are delightful and almost every page has extra funny details tucked into the footnotes.

How do you get a reluctant reader to pick up a book and read?

I think most of the time readers are reluctant because either they struggle with reading, or they haven’t found something that they like, or both. So sometimes it’s a matter of figuring out what is causing the reluctance. For me, I’m thinking a lot about this when I’m purchasing books for the library. I try to have a wide selection of books about specific topics I know my students are interested in that are written at an accessible reading level. I also try to give students a platform to share what they are reading, because reluctant readers are often more likely to listen to their peers when they recommend a book.

You’re also a photographer. Does reading influence your camera work?

I never thought about the connection! But, yes, I think the two passions influence each other. Both reading and photography require a level of intentionality and focus. It’s choosing to block out time, and distractions, and be present with the story or the image. I find both activities really helpful for me mentally, to give myself a chance to slow down and connect with the world and with myself as a person.

What was the last book you read that challenged your world view?

Last summer, I was reading Oak Flat: A Fight for Sacred Land in the American West around the same time I listened to the podcast This Land hosted by Rebecca Nagle. And that combination made me aware of how little I really understood land sovereignty and the ongoing fight for recognition of the full status & rights of Native people in the United States.

What book would you recommend to heal a broken heart?

I think it depends if you want to sit with the sadness or escape from it. There is room for both in the healing process. One of my favorites for sitting with the sadness (but with still an element of hope) is the book Persuasion, by Jane Austen. Jane Austen captures really beautifully in that book the specific pain of mourning what might have been. For trying to still see the good in the world while experiencing personal pain, I would recommend The Catalog of Unabashed Gratitude, by Ross Gay.

What is a favorite quote from a book?

“You can’t see the future coming– not the terrors, for sure, but you also can’t see the wonders that are coming, the moments of light-soaked joy that await each of us.” – John Green, The Anthropocene Reviewed

If you had a Narnia closet, what literary world would it lead to and what’s the first thing you would do there?

My college roommate wrote an incredible series that reimagined Pride and Prejudice as a fantasy called the Heartstone trilogy. I would love to have a Narnia closet where I could see her vision come to life. The first thing I would do is probably get a ride on a dragon.

You’re on a dating app and all your matches are literary characters. Who do you select?

Mr. Bingley from Pride and Prejudice 🙂

In your opinion, what books should win the Newbery and Caldecott medals this year?

My students in our school’s version of the Caldecott for this year selected Gibberish by Young Vo, so I would have to agree with their decision for that one. For the Newbery, I would pick Swim Team by Johnnie Christmas.

NOTE: The 2023 Newbery went to Freewater by Amina Luqman-Dawson and the Caldecott went to Hot Dog by Doug Salati.

Thank you, Beth, for sharing your reading with us!

If you are a Reader and would like to do a profile with me, contact me at patricia.uttaro @ gmail.com.

Reader Profiles

Reader Profile – Taylor Ellis, the Secondhand Librarian


My name is Taylor Ellis and I am a 27 year small business owner, living in Rochester, NY. I currently own a bookstore called The Secondhand Librarian that focuses on the intersection of accessibility and sustainability. All of the books I offer are either secondhand or donated, and are all priced at a reasonable cost so that reading is something anyone can have access to. I live in the Park Ave area with my husband Ryan, and our all Black cat, Miso. I moved here from the DMV area to be with my husband and although I’m not a Rochester native, I’ve quickly grown to call this place home.

Would you rather meet your favorite author or your favorite character?

I would rather meet my favorite character! Rhysand from A Court of Thorns and Roses.

What book changed your life, or changed how you view the world? In what
way?

Matilda by Ronald Dahl! It was hands down my favorite book as a child and made me feel so comforted. I felt very much like her and would often run to books for an escape from the world around me. To be clear, my life was very different from hers as I had two loving parents and a stable childhood however, I always felt like the odd one out and Matilda was my fictional best friend.

Who would be your fictional soulmate?

Casteel! He is from From Blood and Ash or Rhysand!

Are you a solitary reader or social reader?

I am the worst buddy reader! My book interests are also very diverse and sometimes I end up reading a NYT Bestseller and other times I end up reading fanfiction and I just couldn’t put anyone through that.

Fiction or nonfiction?

Fiction! Reading is an escape for me so I enjoy getting lost in another world!

Are you a “finisher” or do you stop reading a book if you’re not connecting with it?

I will stop if I’m not connecting with the book. I feel like there are so many good books out there with so little time so if I don’t like it, I simply move on!

What book should everyone read?

Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides. This was one of my favorite thrillers, hands down, and it was so well done because I had no idea that the plot twist was going to occur.

Is there a book you wish you never read?

I read a book called Baby Teeth and it was hands down the worst thing I read. I’m often generous with my book ratings but this book was very difficult for me to get through content wise. I don’t want to give much away but overall, it just felt like there was no reconciliation at the end and it just made me feel very letdown. Just a lot of trauma and no healing.

What book would you love to see made into a movie? Who would play the lead role?

A Curse So Dark And Lonely. It’s just a wonderful trilogy that I would love to see come to life. I imagine Harper would be played by Chloe Bailey who is also starring in the live action of The Little Mermaid. I think she would make a wonderful Harper.

Why do you read?

I read because I enjoy diving into worlds that don’t look like the one I am currently in. It’s a nice use of the imagination. It’s one of my favorite things to do.

Thanks to Taylor for sharing her thoughts on reading. If you are a Reader or an Author and are interested in having a profile or spotlight here, please contact me at patricia.uttaro (at) gmail.com.

Reader Profiles, Uncategorized

Reader Profile – Adam Traub


mendozaAdam is the Associate Director of the Monroe County Library System. Before joining MCLS in 2019, he had spent the past 15 years in academic libraries, primarily interested in consortial programs around resource sharing. He’s worked at the University of Rochester, RIT, St. John Fisher, and Strong Museum of Play. Adam grew up around Rochester and has been living in the city since 2005, currently living in the South Wedge with his partner. When he’s not working or advocating for libraries, you can find him cooking, running with his dog, or playing Ultimate (frisbee).

 

Write a one-sentence description of yourself as a Reader.

Sporadically voracious – that is not a sentence, but it’s accurate.

What are you reading right now?

Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel

The desert island question – What 5 books would you have to have with you if you were stranded on a desert island?

Are you a finisher? In other words, are you compelled to finish a book even if you hate it? What are some books that you’ve had to force yourself to finish, or which you’ve bailed on?

It took me many years to be able to put down a book but I’ve decided my time is too precious to waste on a book I don’t like. “The Savage Detectives” is one I bailed on that comes to mind.

Do you ever read the end of a book first? Why or why not?

Never! I hate spoilers so much, I avoid any summaries. For example, I had no idea what Station Eleven was about when I picked it up just before the COVID crisis hit us. Ugh – this will be a tough one to get through right now.

What is at the top of your To Be Read pile?

Once published, the third book in the Kingkiller Chronicle. Though, the second in the Founders Trilogy is supposed to be out shortly – I imagine I’ll tackle that ASAP.

Who is your go-to author when someone asks you for a recommendation?

Depending on the someone, I’d go for Patrick Rothfuss or Robert Jackson Bennett. Though, it really depends on what they like. If they aren’t into fantasy, I’d probably suggest Chabon or Winters.

Would you rather be your favorite author or your favorite character?

Well, my favorite author is dead and most of my favorite characters are pretty flawed. I’m content being me and enjoying them from a nice armchair.

Has any book defined your life, as in you would be a different person if you hadn’t read it?

The Hobbit. I was – decidedly – not a reader until high school. If it wasn’t for my uncle introducing me to Tolkien, I don’t think I’d be a librarian today.

Is there a genre or type that you are over and wish would just go away?

No – Ranganathan’s Third Law: “Every book its reader.”

Describe your favorite place to read.

My skin warmed – either by a campfire or equatorial sun, preferably with a dog nearby.

Book or movie? Is there a movie that you think was better than the book?

I enjoy both so much, I don’t know I can make a blanket statement. Casino Royale, perhaps?

What is your preferred format? Hardcover, paperback, digital, audio, doesn’t matter?

I prefer physical books, though I’m not too picky on their binding. One day, though, I’ll be thankful for a nice e-reader where I can make the text bigger.

Share a favorite quote from a book you’ve read. Why is it meaningful to you?

“Not all those who wander are lost.” – JRR Tolkien
It reminds me to enjoy life’s detours, but also to reserve judgment when someone else takes a different path.

What book are you recommending that everyone read right now?

I loved Foundryside and I’m really looking forward to the next in the series. Though, if I’m honest, “Name of the Wind.” Not only is it a great fantasy story, but I hope the increased sales urge the author to finish the series!

What book challenged you the most when you read it?

Native Son by Richard Wright. Growing up in a predominantly white middle-class neighborhood, in a predominantly white middle-class school district, surrounded by predominantly white middle-class – well, I had – and do have – a lot of learning to do. I’m grateful for my teachers who selected that as a part of the curriculum.