Author: Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Partner. Parent. Reader. Retired Library Director in Rochester NY.
Detective, Magical, Mystery, New Releases, Suspense, United Kingdom, Women

A Gargoyle’s Guide to Murder by Gigi Pandian

Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Description

A vanished body. A deadly bookshop. A country house party full of suspects. Can a living gargoyle and an alchemist decipher the clues before poisoned pages claim another victim?

Dorian Robert-Houdin is used to living his life in the shadows, his existence only known to a few trusted friends. When a dangerous book from his past resurfaces, he follows his closest confidante, alchemist Zoe Faust, from Oregon to England to investigate.

Before he can examine the magical book, Dorian witnesses a murder amidst the foggy lanes of Oxford. But when he takes Zoe to the scene, there’s no body—and no evidence a crime has taken place. Using his unique skills as a gargoyle, Dorian sets out to solve the baffling crime nobody else believes occurred.

When Dorian and Zoe discover a dead man in a bookshop filled with arsenic-laced books, the victim isn’t a stranger—he’s connected to the vanishing crime scene. The trail leads to a country house party where a group of bibliophile suspects have gathered and a storm is brewing. Could the killer be the mercurial Agatha Christie scholar? The prickly literature professor? The secretive rare books expert? With an unscrupulous book thief lurking, can sleuths Dorian and Zoe unmask a murderer before the next page brings them to a perilous end?

A Gargoyle’s Guide to Murder is the eagerly awaited new installment in the award-winning cozy fantasy mystery series by USA Today bestselling author Gigi Pandian. Perfect for fans of the quirky charm and found family of Only Murders in the Building and books by Ellery Adams and Travis Baldree. 

My Thoughts

Gigi Pandian’s books just keep getting better!

I have been a fan of the Accidental Alchemist series for years so was thrilled to get an early copy of this one. I was not disappointed. My favorite characters are back – Zoe, Max, and of course Dorian! This time, they are in London checking up on Non Degenera Alchemica, the horrible backwards alchemy book that nearly killed Dorian in a previous book.

As Zoe and Co. get more and more involved with the current iteration of the book, the reader is treated to some wonderful storytelling. I also appreciated the added “country house murder” trope part way through the book, which added a comical element to the story given Dorian’s project of writing a handbook on investigating murder. And the surprise twist at the end? Wonderful!

Overall, this is a solid mystery – well-plotted and paced with good descriptive narrative. I do recommend reading the previous books in the series before you open this one, but this could be a stand-alone read and a nice introduction to the series.

Publication Date: October 7, 2025
Published By: Gargoyle Girl Productions
Thanks to Netgalley for the review copy

Detective, Family, Mystery, New Releases, Suspense

The Killing Stones by Ann Cleeves

Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Description

The Killing Stones marks the eagerly awaited return of Ann Cleeves’ beloved detective Jimmy Perez from the Shetland series, and a gripping new investigation with a stunning new setting.

It’s been several years since Detective Jimmy Perez left Shetland. He has settled into his new home in Orkney, the group of islands, off the northern coast of Scotland, with his partner Willow Reeve and their growing family. One stormy winter night, his oldest and closest friend, Archie Stout, goes missing. Ever the detective, Perez catches a boat to the island of Westray, where Archie worked as a farmer and lived with his wife and children.

But when he arrives he finds a shocking scene: Archie’s body, on an archaeological dig site and an ancient Westray story stone with precise spirals carved into it beside him, the clear murder weapon. The artifact, taken from a nearby museum, seems to suggest a premediated murder.

But Perez is so close to the case that he struggles to maintain an objective distance from the potential suspects. He finds it difficult to question Archie’s wife, whom he’s known for years. Rumors swirl about the dead man’s relationship with a young woman new to the island, an artist. With each new lead, the case becomes more twisted and Perez wonders if he will ever find out what happened in his friend’s final days.

My Thoughts

A new Jimmy Perez story? YES PLEASE!

As usual, Cleeves deliver a wonderfully intricate story full of colorful characters, this time set in the Orkney islands versus Shetland. Readers get to know a whole new landscape and set of people, steeped in folklore and emotions.

We are introduced to a new set of characters who are every bit as gritty and real as the folks Perez left behind in Shetland. Plus, we learn more about Perez’ own past and his early relationships. At the core of this one is tragedy and heartbreak, with the theme of family tradition shattered by 21st century technology.

While I had an inkling of the villain about midway, I really didn’t want it to be true. However, this provided a vehicle for Cleeves to write a whole range of emotions for Perez and his friends on Orkney.

I can’t recommend Ann Cleeves’ work enough. She truly is one of the very best authors writing atmospheric, complex crime fiction today. If you haven’t read her books, what are you waiting for??

Superbly done.

Advanced Praise

“Ann Cleeves’s elegance as a wordsmith, the ingenuity of her plots, and the depth of her characters can be matched by few writers. In The Killing Stones she brings back the beloved Jimmy Perez in a tale that highlights the entire spectrum of her formidable talents… This novel is more than worth every minute you spend with it.”—David Baldacci, #1 New York Times bestselling author

“The Killing Stones is classic Ann Cleeves: a complex mystery, beloved characters, and a setting so vivid you can feel the chill of wind and rain on your face.”

—Tess Gerritsen, New York Times bestselling author of The Summer Guests

Publication Date: September 30, 2025
Published By: St. Martin’s Press, Minotaur Books
Thanks to Netgalley for the review copy

British, Historical, Mystery

Murder at Holly House by Denzil Meyrick

Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Description

A festive mystery perfect for fans of Murder on the Christmas Express and Agatha Christie’s Hercule Poirot’s Christmas

A village of secrets.

Yorkshire, 1952. Christmas is fast approaching when a dead stranger is found lodged up the chimney of Holly House in the snow-covered village of Elderby. Is he a simple thief, or a would-be killer?

A mystery that can’t be solved.

Inspector Frank Grasby is ordered to investigate. But as is often the way for him, things don’t go according to plan.

A Christmas to remember.

When the local doctor’s husband is murdered, Grasby begins to realize that everyone in Elderby is hiding something.

And if he can’t uncover the truth soon, the whole country will pay a dreadful price…

My Thoughts

I started this expecting the usual clever country house murder mystery and instead got a rough and tumble few days that could have shook the world. The writing reminded me of old Golden Age dialect-driven mysteries, with the lovable screw-up main character who turns out to be much more than you initially think.

Meyrick does a wonderful job of describing the Yorkshire moors – snow, sleepy policemen, irritating peers, and more snow – but it’s the story that shines here.

I expected the country house thing and instead got a bit of The Secret Adversary and The Thirty Nine Steps crossed with Albert Campion (if Campion were a vicar’s son). The relationship between Frank and Deedee was written with a nice blend of comedy and drama.

On the whole, this will appeal to readers who appreciate a good, old-fashioned, save-the-world whodunit told with a bit of whimsy.

Recommended.

Publication Date: October 7, 2025
Published By: Poisoned Pen Press
Thanks to Netgalley for the review copy

Historical, Mystery

The Face Stealer by Sarah Rayne

Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Description

A puzzling mystery pulls the thieving Fitzglen family back to a shocking crime committed in the time of Catherine the Great in this third instalment of the spellbinding Theatre of Thieves gothic mystery series, set in Victorian England.

London, 1909. The Fitzglens combine running London’s finest theatre with a very profitable side-line in stealing. But while they might be thieves, they still have principles. They never pinch anything their victim couldn’t afford to lose.

When a stranger approaches Jack Fitzglen after a performance, claiming that a Fitzglen has committed a grave crime in his village in faraway Russia, Jack knows exactly who’s to blame: the unpleasant Saintly Simeon, who was chucked out of the family for breaking their code.

Simeon has stolen three valuable, and oddly frightening, Stone Heads, the likenesses of children who vanished over a century ago. The Heads were locked away from the world in a remote Russian monastery . . . though whether to protect the priceless sculptures, or to protect the villagers from the Heads themselves, no one can say.

Jack joins forces with fellow actor Viola Gilfillan to retrieve the stolen goods and put things right. But as they investigate, peeling the layers of history back to the treacherous court of Catherine the Great herself, the ominous power of the Stone Heads begins to draw them down into a darkness from which they may never be able to escape . . .

This unsettling gothic historical mystery from acclaimed British author Sarah Rayne will appeal to fans of Daphne du Maurier, Laura Purcell, Rebecca James, Sarah Waters and Stuart Turton.

My Thoughts

Sarah Rayne keeps coming up with fascinating plots and this one is just spectacular. We’re once again immersed in the world of the FitzGlen family of actors/thieves who only “filch” from people who can afford it. Here we are treated to an origin story that explains how the family came to own the Amaranths Theatre where they perform their popular plays. The story of patriarch Harry FitzGlen’s relationship with Catherine the Great is done with Rayne’s usual one-two punch of softness (their relationship) then a quick jab to the throat (murder & court intrigue).

Rayne excels in writing creepy characters that make your skin crawl and Brother Quintus is no exception. He’s wily, deceitful, sly, and most certainly unhinged. His role in the plot to murder Peter III and the follow up to that is shiver-inducing.

I continue to be stymied by the fact that so many of my American friends don’t know about this fabulous author. All of her series are well-researched and skillfully written, and most of them bone-chillingly scary. The Face Stealer is one of the best horror mysteries I’ve read in a while.

Recommended for those looking for a clever, knuckle-whitening story of historical murder and mayhem.

Publication Date: August 5, 2025
Published By: Severn House
Thanks to Netgalley for the review copy

Biography, Family

Karen: A Brother Remembers by Kelsey Grammer

Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Description

On July 1, 1975, Kelsey Grammer’s younger sister, eighteen-year-old Karen Grammer, was raped and murdered. In Karen: A Brother Remembers, Kelsey reveals their past, celebrates their youth together, mourns her loss, and unearths his struggle for faith and healing in the decades since her death.

Through this memoir, Grammer poignantly recounts the memories of his sister and the impact her loss had on his life and family. With raw honesty, Grammer explores the profound grief and devastation that followed Karen’s death, as well as the long and arduous journey toward healing. He bravely confronts the pain of losing a loved one to senseless violence, offering readers a glimpse into the complexities of coping with such a profound loss.

Karen also serves as a testament to Grammer’s lifelong journey with grief and his struggle to defeat the sting of death with the memory of a life filled with joy—irreplaceable joy. In sharing his story, Grammer aims to help others who have experienced similar loss, offering solace and encouragement to cherish the love they knew, however brief, on their own path toward healing.

This book is a moving tribute to Karen and the brother’s love that survives her.

My Thoughts

This new book from actor Kelsey Grammer is not an easy reading experience.

Grammer recounts the shocking murder of his younger sister and his own experience with heartrending grief, anger, and loss. Told in a sort of stream of consciousness, not all readers will like the jumpiness of the narrative. I experienced a bit of skepticism about Grammer including photos and descriptive text illustrating his career, his successes, marriages, and so on. However, I realized that he had to do that in order to fully develop the story of what his life has been like without Karen – all the wonderful things she’s missed and the things he’s had to celebrate without her.

Having known people lost to violence, I felt like Grammer skillfully conveyed the absolutely unhinged way you feel in the aftermath of such an horrific event.

This is a very emotional read and could be triggering for people who have experienced violent loss, rape, or murder.

Publication Date: May 6, 2025
Published By: Harper Select
Thanks to the Greece Public Library for the book

Historical, Mystery, Women

Murder in Minature by Katie Tietjen

Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Netgalley Description

The second installment in the Maple Bishop historical mysteries continues the adventures of intrepid amateur sleuth Maple Bishop.

Inspired by the real-life mother of forensic science, Frances Glessner Lee, this smartly plotted series will appeal to fans of Rhys Bowen.

In post-WWII Vermont, Maple Bishop has a thriving dollhouse business and a new career as a crime scene consultant for the local sheriff’s office. On the surface, she seems to be doing well, but deep down Maple is still reeling from the death of her husband. When the body of an aspiring firefighter–who was close childhood friends with Kenny, the sheriff’s deputy and Maple’s confidante–is discovered in the charred remains of a burned cabin, Maple is called in to help determine whether the fire was an accident or a case of murder by arson.

Realizing there’s more to the crime than meets the eye, she sets out to unearth the discrepancies from the scene by re-creating the cabin in miniature. The investigation leads them to Maple’s old Boston neighborhood, forcing her to confront the past she’s desperately trying to forget. 

As Maple and Kenny sift through clues, they uncover dark secrets that hit close to home, unraveling in unexpected ways—and putting their lives in danger.

My Thoughts

Mystery readers looking for something more than a cozy and less than hardcore police procedural will fully appreciate this offering from Katie Tietjen. With main character Maple based on the “mother of forensic science,” it would be hard to go astray.

Maple will appeal to many readers, as her attention to detail in constructing her miniature dollhouses and in her approach to solving a gruesome murder is pretty brilliant. (I admit, though, the miniatures reminded me of the CSI Las Vegas story thread that featured a serial killer who made miniatures of their death scenes.)

Maple is reminiscent of an American Maisie Dobbs, and fans of that series will certainly enjoy this one. There is also a fairly overt suggestion that Maple may have some sensory issues, which again will appeal to some readers as the issues are handled with sensitivity.

Overall, this is a solid mystery and a series I will definitely read again.

Publication Date: September 23, 2025
Published By: Crooked Lane Books
Thanks to Netgalley for the review copy

Book Tour, Detective, Mystery, Partners In Crime, Suspense

Throwing Shadows by Claire Booth

Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Virtual Book Tour – August 4 – 29, 2025

Description

A Sheriff Hank Worth Mystery

When a hiker stumbles from the woods raving about a dead man, Sheriff Hank Worth launches a search. Near the infamous landmark of Murder Rocks – a Civil War era hideout for ambushers who robbed and killed passing travelers – they unearth two bodies and a skeleton.

Local legend says there’s caches of stolen gold buried in the area. And – thanks to some recent nationwide publicity – the Ozark backwoods are now swarming with out-of-town treasure hunters, who have little concern for Hank’s murder investigation. With the clock ticking, Hank must identify the victims . . . and the killer. But could the new pursuit of long-lost plunder really have led to multiple deaths?

My Thoughts

The Hank Worth series is new to me so I did find some of the content which referred to previous books unfamiliar. However, none of that content (and my lack of reference) intrudes on the author’s ability to tell one hell of a story.

For me, the sign of a really, really good author is their ability to write a series that carries a thread throughout but with each entry able to stand on its own. That is accomplished by solid and clever storytelling supported by well-developed and interesting characters. All of that and more is here in Throwing Shadows.

The story which drives the action is fascinating – murder and mayhem on the backroads of the Ozarks during a very dark time in American history, lost gold, and plenty of intrigue coupled with 21st century treasure-hunting and podcasting. This is what kept me reading.

The back stories of the characters, particularly Hank Worth, didn’t really grab me because of my unfamiliarity with the series, but I liked this one well enough that I’ll now go back and read the rest of the series. I’m looking forward to some very enjoyable reading!

Book Details

Genre: Crime Fiction, Police Procedural
Published by: Severn House Publishers
Publication Date: August 5, 2025
Number of Pages:  240 
ISBN: 9781448313914 (ISBN10: 1448313910) eBook
Series:A Sheriff Hank Worth Mystery, Book 7

Shortlinks

Author Links: 

Website https://pictbooks.tours/ULtH8R
Amazon Author https://pictbooks.tours/mWLMfRzR
Goodreads https://pictbooks.tours/6MJ9JydS
BookBub https://pictbooks.tours/QZnXDawn
Instagram https://pictbooks.tours/4FM950gZ
Twitter https://pictbooks.tours/swdlkoFI
Facebook https://pictbooks.tours/oHKRA0Po
BlueSky https://pictbooks.tours/4eMVQ36R
Severn House – https://pictbooks.tours/hWKcZK25

Retail Links:

Amazon – https://pictbooks.tours/24v7ZHiK
BN – https://pictbooks.tours/HZmYbGHP
BookShop.org – https://pictbooks.tours/97ZhoIHn
Goodreads – https://pictbooks.tours/0TV0taZ8
BookBub – https://pictbooks.tours/gabUe0Gf
booksamillion https://pictbooks.tours/6Qw3PlBw
Severn House – https://pictbooks.tours/hWKcZK25

Hank Worth Mystery Series:

Amazon https://pictbooks.tours/y7pfAoFb
PICT Tour Page https://pictbooks.tours/F0yHpLH9
Giveaway https://pictbooks.tours/iXiXJFB0

—

Publisher: Severn House

Instagram @severnhouseimprint
Threads @severnhouseimprint
Twitter @severnhouse
Facebook @severnhouse

Author Bio

Claire Booth is a former newspaper reporter whose writing career has taken her from Missouri to Washington, D.C., South Florida, the Seattle area, and the Bay Area. She’s reported on many high-profile cases, including the Laci Peterson murder and the San Francisco dog mauling case. The case of a deadly cult leader became the subject of her nonfiction book, The False Prophet: Conspiracy, Extortion and Murder in the Name of God. After spending so much time covering crimes so strange and convoluted they seemed more like fiction than reality, she had enough of the real world and decided to write novels instead. Her acclaimed Sheriff Hank Worth mystery series takes place in Branson, Missouri, where the small-town Ozarks meet big-city country music tourism.

Visit Claire Booth at:

www.ClaireBooth.com
Amazon Author Profile
Goodreads
BookBub
Instagram – @claire.booth10
X – @claire.booth10
Facebook – @claireboothauthor
Severn House

Cookbooks, Historical

The Gilded Age Christmas Cookbook by Becky Libourel Diamond

Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Description

Although most Americans have heard of sugar plums thanks to the famous holiday poem A Visit from St. Nicholas by Clement Clarke Moore, many have likely never have had the pleasure of tasting one of these luxuries, or even know what they really are (hint: they are not sugar-dusted plums). This is because sugar plums are one of the Gilded Age era holiday sweets that got eclipsed as America moved into the twentieth century. But The Gilded Age Christmas Cookbook will bridge the past and present, bringing back sugar plums and other confections not typically found in modern cookbooks, while revisiting some beloved favorites. 

With origins that date back to the nineteenth century and even earlier, the recipes in The Gilded Age Christmas Cookbook have been adapted for today’s ingredients and appliances, allowing cooks to recreate them in their own modern kitchens. Each recipe will provide a colorful glimpse into the era, featuring the fascinating history behind each cookie, its ingredients and baking methods. There will also be sidebars throughout, offering tidbits of Christmas lore of the era. 

A perfect gift to bring sparkle to the holiday season for anyone who enjoys food, history, culture and Christmas traditions, The Gilded Age Christmas Cookbook is a unique way to revitalize any baker’s holiday repertoire while looking to past foodways for inspiration. With all the opulence and enchanting allure of the Victorian period, this nostalgic book is chock-full of delicious holiday treats.

My Thoughts

The author has done an admirable job of culling interesting, sometimes esoteric, facts about Christmas from an amazing array of sources and turning that dry history into a readable, very entertaining exposition of holiday traditions of the Gilded Age.

Digging deep into the roots of many of our current holiday traditions and giving the origin stories new life with short, well-crafted paragraphs complemented by lovely illustrations, The Gilded Age Christmas Cookbook is an absolute delight to read. I especially enjoyed the section on games and may use some of the old time games in modified versions for the always-dreaded ice-breaker games in the business world!

However, I think I’ll leave Snapdragon to history. What a time it was when children were allowed to play that game!

Also notable is the inclusion of Black Christmas traditions such as the work by the Ida B. Wells Women’s Club and the Christmas balls held by Philadelphia’s Crescent Club. Also included are Jewish Hanukkah traditions that were practiced during the Gilded Age, along with the recipes for things like sufganiyot.

While the recipes and their backstories are interesting and well-adapted for 21st century cooking, I didn’t find anything new, but I am an avid reader of Christmas recipes, so someone who is relatively new to Christmas cooking and baking will surely find many recipes that will become family favorites.

The lore appears to be well-researched and is presented in an interesting manner.

Publication Date: August 5, 2025
Published By: Globe Pequot
Thanks to Netgalley for the review copy

Cozy, Mystery, New Releases, Suspense

Sugar and Spite by Carol Perry

Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Description

There’s no place like Salem, Massachusetts—aka “the witch city”—for Halloween. As residents embrace their historic heritage to celebrate the season, WICH-TV program director Lee Barrett is assigned the decadent task of highlighting the village’s delectable sweet shops—only to learn that some revelers prefer deadly tricks over delicious treats . . .

Casa del Chocolate is one of Salem’s most charming boutique candy shops, making it a perfect profile story. Although preoccupied with her own personal sweet news—Lee and her detective husband Pete Mondello are expecting a bundle of joy—she cheerfully agrees to interview the chocolatier. Since becoming pregnant, the radiant and exhilarated mother-to-be has discovered that she is finally free of the unwanted haunting “visions” she has endured since childhood.

Shirley Parker inherited Casa del Chocolate, housed in her beautiful ancestral home on the waterfront, continuing her family’s sweet tradition of conjuring magical treats for the folks of Salem. Mesmerized by the delightful chocolate scented aromas filling the air while touring the kitchen, Lee is shocked when she stumbles upon the murdered body of Barney Bingham, Shirley’s estranged husband.

As the police focus their suspicions on Shirley, Lee learns that many people had reasons for wanting Barney dead. Now, with help from Pete, tarot reader River North, and clairvoyant gentleman cat O’Ryan, as well as some new feline friends, Lee must unmask the true killer—and cope with the sudden return of her troubling “visions”. . .

My Thoughts

I so enjoy Carol Perry’s Witch City series and was delighted to find Perry at the top of her game in this newest entry. Lee and Pete and their Salem crew of friends and co-workers are back in a story that clocks in as a bit more serious and mysterious than some earlier entries. All the familiar faces are there, along with a new set of old acquaintances, one of whom shows up dead early on.

Perry is excellent as playing “cat and mouse” with her readers, and that is surely how I felt while reading this one. I kept going back and forth between two suspects and was truly surprised at the end.

The mystery is clever and well-plotted, the characters by turns charming and provocative. All in all, a winner. If you haven’t read Witch City mysteries, you could read this as a stand-alone, but I recommend reading the entire series.

I will say though that the last couple pages really felt a bit like a chapter closing on this series. If that is the case, I hope Perry might consider picking it up again and making Ella Marie the star in a new middle grade series!

Publication Date: October 28, 2025
Published By: Kensington Publishing; Kensington Cozies
Thanks to Netgalley for the review copy

Reading

Every Book Its Reader

Patricia McDonald Uttaro

Or Books That Are Not For Me

Librarians will recognize Ranganathan’s Third Law of Library Science*: “Every Book Its Reader,” meaning of course that not every book is meant for every reader, but all books are meant for A reader.

When I retired, I was determined to start working through my To Be Read list, starting with my Goodreads account. I started adding titles I wanted to read as early as 2007, so I decided to start with the earliest ones.

A couple have been great reads: Moloka’i by Alan Brennert and Otherlands by Thomas Halliday.

Others were not meant for this reader:

  • Life After Life by Kate Atkinson – I usually enjoy Atkinson’s work, but this one just did not resonate. I found the repetition boring and irritating after several chapters. Fascinating premise, but just not for me.
  • Mrs. Poe by Lynn Cullen – An odd fictional exploration of Edgar Allan Poe’s relationship with his young wife. Dark, brooding, and very creepy.
  • The Resurrectionist: the lost work of Spencer Black – If Mrs. Poe was dark and creepy, this one was ghoulish and bizarre.
  • Indian Burial Ground by Nick Medina – Enjoyed the first half but had to put it down when it got super gruesome. Not a fan.

I am moving on to more from the list – The River of No Return by Bee Ridgeway and The Malice of Fortune by Michael Ennis. Hoping these live up to the hype of 13 years ago!

Not on my old Goodreads list but a couple I read recently that also missed the mark for me:

  • Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil by V.E. Schwab – Schwab is one of the more literate authors writing today. Her narrative is always beautifully rendered and this book is no exception. However I am just so done with vampire stories. And really, Anne Rice wrote this story 50 years ago. Not a favorite read for me but I imagine it will be a blockbuster.
  • Careless People: A Cautionary Tale of Power, Greed, and Lost Idealism by Sarah Wynn-Williams – While I think the author wants us to see her as a brave whistleblower, she must certainly bear some of the blame for the heinous things she describes. You don‘t live and work like that for so long without being complicit. Overall, I was deeply disappointed and often horrified at the ridiculous behavior and dangerous decision-making that results when ordinary people acquire an unimaginable amount of money and power.

*If you’re curious about the Five Laws of Library Science, here they are – https://www.librarianshipstudies.com/2017/09/five-laws-of-library-science.html